The dynamic between Paul McCartney and John Lennon is one of the most fascinating aspects of The Beatles’ history. Their songwriting partnership, despite the differences in their personalities and creative approaches, helped produce some of the most iconic music of the 20th century. However, it wasn’t uncommon for Lennon and McCartney to criticize each other’s work, even after their partnership dissolved. One of the most notable examples of Lennon praising McCartney’s work, despite their personal and professional differences, was his admiration for the song “Here, There and Everywhere.”
In a 1980 interview with Playboy, Lennon commented on McCartney's songwriting abilities and gave a rare but significant compliment to "Here, There and Everywhere." He called it “one of his best.” This moment was notable because Lennon was often critical of McCartney’s later work, accusing it of being overly sentimental or shallow. However, Lennon saw something in this track that stood out, and his comment carried an additional weight given the complexities of their relationship.
Released on Revolver in 1966, "Here, There and Everywhere" is one of McCartney’s most delicate and heartfelt ballads. It contrasts with some of the more experimental and energetic tracks on the album, like “Eleanor Rigby” or “Tomorrow Never Knows.” The song was inspired by The Beach Boys, particularly their album Pet Sounds, which had a profound impact on McCartney. He once mentioned that he had been listening to Brian Wilson’s “God Only Knows” when the inspiration for “Here, There and Everywhere” struck him.
Musically, the song is complex yet subtle. The soft harmonies and intricate chord changes give it a unique texture, while the lyrics reflect a deep sense of love and longing. The words are simple but evocative, capturing the essence of being in love and wanting to be with someone in every possible way. McCartney’s vocals are tender and restrained, matching the mood of the song perfectly.
Lennon’s recognition of McCartney’s effort on this track is significant because it speaks to one of the fundamental differences between the two as songwriters. Lennon was known for his raw, emotional, and often cynical approach to songwriting. His songs were deeply personal, frequently reflecting his own inner struggles and the world around him. McCartney, on the other hand, was more likely to write songs that were melodic, optimistic, and rooted in a sense of timelessness. Lennon often dismissed McCartney’s songs as too “light” or lacking in depth. However, in “Here, There and Everywhere,” Lennon saw a balance between McCartney’s musicality and emotional depth.
Lennon’s comment, “He could write if he took the effort,” can be interpreted as both praise and a subtle jab. While he acknowledged McCartney’s talent, he also implied that McCartney didn’t always push himself to reach his full potential. This statement reflects the competitive and sometimes antagonistic nature of their partnership. They constantly pushed each other, even if it came with friction. The tension between them, both musically and personally, contributed to the magic of The Beatles. Their rivalry spurred them on to greater heights, and songs like “Here, There and Everywhere” are a testament to that creative tension.
In conclusion, "Here, There and Everywhere" remains a high point in Paul McCartney's illustrious career, not just for its beauty and craftsmanship but also because of the rare admiration it received from John Lennon. Lennon’s acknowledgment of the song speaks volumes about McCartney's talent and the potential he saw in his former bandmate. The song stands as a reminder of McCartney’s ability to combine emotional resonance with musical sophistication, a quality that Lennon, despite their differences, could not help but respect.
